www.derf.net / movies / 20051108_He_Loves_Me_He_Loves_Me_Not /
<< prev in "movie reviews" movie reviews

He Loves Me... He Loves Me Not   ...   movie reviews
tue 2005-nov-08 01:37:41 pst   ...   permalink

Sunday night we watched He Loves Me... He Loves Me Not (French title: A la folie... pas du tout). It was good, though it suffered a bit from the "plot summary reveals too much" problem -- I think I would have liked it better if I'd known less going in.

<spoiler detail="medium">

So I guess I'd read something (maybe the back of the DVD case back when I used to go to the video store) which revealed that the story is told first from her perspective and then from his, as the film goes from romance to thriller... So during the first half I knew not to trust her view of events, and so on.

One interesting thing about it is that the way they do it, there's nothing in the first half that's actually lying to the audience -- it simply misleads us through clever editing. So it's sort of an example of the "unreliable narrator" literary device, but in a somewhat different way. Perhaps the more literal unreliable narrator works better in text than film; and in film it works better to accomplish it through careful inclusion and omission? I dunno.


In any case, as usual, Audrey Tautou gives a good performance, and she's reason enough to see it.

mail me

reader comments on this entry:

sat 2006-may-27 14:11:42 pdt
posted by

i knew nothing about this movie short of the fact that tautou starred in it. definitely a fabulous movie! i also had the good fortune to view "silence of the lambs" under the same conditions (well, except it was jodie foster) and the same results.

nice to see the derfblog back in action!

name (required):

email (will be publicly viewable only if no URL given):

personal URL:

remember name/email/URL in a cookie
don't save info in a cookie

comments (required):

NOTE: html tags cannot be included in the above. however, blank lines will separate paragraphs, and if you care, some rudimentary formatting is available with the following html-like tags (but note the square instead of angle brackets):

text[br]more text
more text
[quote]some quoted text[/quote]
some quoted text
[link url="http://www.example.com/"]somewhere else[/link]
somewhere else

NeilFred Picciotto drawing of neilfred
  • derf content, blog-style
  • derf's comics
  • elsewhere on the web
  • 100% true stories
  • what i learned today
  • random thoughts
  • movie reviews
  • He Loves Me... He Loves Me Not
  • Serenity
  • Panic
  • Run Lola Run
  • Vertigo
  • . . . more . . .
  • phone photos
  • blog-on-blog action
  • tags
  • RSS feed
  • XFN links
  • recent comments
  • 2008-sep-22
  • Britt Lyons on food handler
  • Conrad Pate on singing nuns
  • Suzy on people live in West Virginia?
  • Quinn Rutledge on chickens
  • Jacquline Gamble on garlic rabbit
  • 2008-sep-21
  • Lenora Gomez on garlic rabbit
  • 2008-sep-20
  • Jonas Bailey on food handler
  • Lenny Ayers on chickens
  • random phone photo random phone photo
  • non-bloggy content
  • the derf himself
  • the derf FAQ
  • other derfs
  • what's new?
  • the derfnet portal
  • derf's comics
    blogs and such
  • Q
  • entropy
  • girlhacker
  • ambiguous
  • oblomovka
  • sem101
  • badgerbag
  • zephoria
  • pith, jcn
  • jvg
  • unlikely words
  • mjr
  • jessajune
  • heaneyland
  • dommah
  • unwellness
  • livejournalers
  • ...  all derf.net blog content and underlying code owned by NeilFred Picciotto  ...
    mail me